Reddit Says Google's AI Search Sends Fewer Visitors. Check Your Website's Traffic.
Reddit's CEO Steve Huffman said this week that Google's AI search is sending fewer people to websites. The Neuron's daily digest, citing the reporting, says Reddit saw an average drop of more than a million weekly Google referrals during October. I haven't seen Reddit's own numbers, so treat that figure as secondhand. The direction matches what I keep hearing from business owners around Toledo, though.
Reddit is a giant, so a million visits is a rounding error to them in some ways. Your site is not a giant. If your phone rings because somebody Googled "roof repair Perrysburg" and clicked your page, even a small slide in those clicks shows up on your calendar.
Why this happens
Google now answers a lot of questions right at the top of the page. The person reads the answer, feels done, and never clicks anything. Reddit gets hit because it's full of answers Google can summarize. A local plumber's service page can get hit the same way when someone asks "how much does it cost to replace a water heater" and Google just tells them a number.
Check your own numbers, takes about ten minutes
Open Google Analytics and look at traffic from Google organic search for the last 90 days. Compare September to October, and compare October of this year to last year if you have it. You're not looking for a perfect answer. You're looking at whether the line is flat, sliding, or sliding on certain pages only.
Then open Google Search Console, which is free, and look at impressions versus clicks. If impressions are up and clicks are down, that's the pattern people are describing. Google is showing your page to more people and fewer of them are tapping it.
If your site doesn't have Analytics or Search Console set up, that's the first fix. You can't manage something you can't see.
What I'd change if clicks are slipping
Stop leaning on pages that only give a generic answer, because Google will just give that answer itself. The pages that still earn clicks are the ones with something Google can't fake, like your actual prices for a typical job, photos of your own work, real reviews, a booking button, and the specific towns you serve. Make a call to action easy to find. If somebody lands on your page, they should be able to call or book in one tap on a phone.
And don't build your whole business on one traffic source. A simple email list of past customers doesn't care what Google does next month. I tell everybody in my workshops the same thing, because the search results page changes about every quarter now.
One honest caveat. One company's October numbers don't prove your traffic is down. Your site might be fine. Look before you spend money fixing something that isn't broken.
I run AI workshops and one-on-one AI consultations for companies around Toledo, Northwest Ohio, and Southeast Michigan. If you want help reading your Analytics and Search Console numbers, email me and we'll go through them together.
Email Jayson